Sunday, July 3, 2022
Resident Entertainment
  • Game Reviews
  • Movie Reviews
  • TV Show Reviews
  • Release Dates
No Result
View All Result
Resident Entertainment
  • Game Reviews
  • Movie Reviews
  • TV Show Reviews
  • Release Dates
No Result
View All Result
Resident Entertainment
Disclaimer: We may earn revenue from links clicked on this page. These links help to support Resident Entertainment and keep our content free for all our readers.

Home Featured Articles

Bioshock Infinite Is Not Game Of The Year

Bryan Weatherall by Bryan Weatherall
July 16, 2013
Reading Time: 5 mins read
A A
0
ShareShareShareShare

Do you remember playing Wolfenstein 3D? Yes, the one before Doom. Okay, now do you remember gliding indiscriminately along walls, hammering the space bar repeatedly as you sought for those hidden rooms and their piles of gold and treasure? While some secret room locations had visual cues in the level design, a ten year old doesn’t have patience for that sort of thing, so slowly disintegrating the space bar was always the best option when I played it. The problem is, after a while this sort of thing loses its appeal. After a while, Bioshock Infinite loses a lot more.

Elizabeth

One of the most glaring issues, for me, with Bioshock Infinite runs parallels with Wolfenstein 3D – looting. Whether it was bodies of enemies not even cold, rubbish bins, desks, safes, etc., I realised later in the game I wasn’t even paying attention to what the hell it was I had just picked up. Ammo? Money? [shrug] There’s this girl who keeps throwing all manner of bullets and money at me, instead of picking up a carbine and, I don’t know, helping out every now and again by nailing a bad guy between the eyes. Don’t ask how we know each other; I suspect it’s overly complex and I haven’t had a drink today. Yet.

I wanted Bioshock Infinite to be good. I needed Bioshock Infinite to be good. The original game set in Rapture was the sort of game I looked forward to – good story, great twist, beautiful aesthetics, claustrophobic settings and enough mystery to drive me constantly forward. Tragically, I realised towards the end of the game, as I resisted chucking the controller, that it had become a grind. Perhaps this is the time to confess I didn’t actually finish, I just couldn’t be bothered, and I found that disturbing. Luckily, I have the attention span of a goldfish when I’m not getting along with a game and got friendly with Naughty Dog’s masterpiece instead. Bioshock Infinite is not Game of the Year.

Before you start spitting venom at your screen, rejecting the unworthy opinion of the non-completer, you need to remember that this is the whole point. Any Game of the Year needs to be so good, so compelling, so utterly addictive that you deny all knowledge of having any family, a job, basic nutritional requirements or the need for sleep until you have completed said masterpiece. And the world of Columbia didn’t step up to the plate.

Bioshock Infinite looked pretty, but only when used in a sentence with novelty. During Booker’s early time strolling around the streets of the floating city, everything looks Nice, with a dash of Pleasantville and while I know this is partly designed to accentuate the contrast with later goings-on, the world had flatness, a two-dimensional tang to it. It seems as though the more detail goes into a videogame, the more its restrictions stand out – unexplorable buildings with unopenable doors should be banned with extreme prejudice. At least The Last of Us (and I will try not to mention this game too much lest my biased fanboyism causes mushrooms to sprout from my ears) gave a credible context to areas you couldn’t access, you could see where people had made desperate last stands, where entry and exit points were reduced because otherwise you were dead.

Unlike Rapture, whose dystopian society mixed horribly well with confined spaces, Columbia contained the grand architectural spaces, both indoors and externally, that seems to be permanently super glued to communism and totalitarian regimes. It might look good on paper, but the AI is damn good at picking you from a distance and I don’t see any of my enemies cursing at their DualShock controller, their clearly decaying reflexes in just their mid-thirties, or wondering why there isn’t a BFG for moments such as this.

Narrative is tricky; there is no denying that the best delivery of a videogame narrative can be sheer genius. Half Life did it by cleverly staying with Freeman at all times, and only allowing the story to be told through what he observed. Bioshock made clever use of audio communication and isolation. The Last of Us (there I go again) through amazing interaction and economy of words. But Columbia was a floating city, where the antagonists would float past or shout over the intercom, sprouting their propaganda, and for someone like me who is as politically aligned as a rainbow trout, I couldn’t give a stuff. I didn’t care about Comstock’s justifications or his political mantra, I just wanted to shut him up. Booker himself was also kept mysterious for the sake of a twist later on. It was a successful ploy in the first Bioshock that felt more like a hindrance in Columbia – I find that seeing a character’s motivations and how they deal with the conflicts they encounter to be far more captivating.

Save damsel in distress? Right. Escape the facility that is about to explode, because you wandered in and pressed the big red button? Gotcha. Shoot the undead thing so it doesn’t eat my face off? Locked and loaded. Anyone who knows me knows not to leave me in a small room with a member of the Young Liberal Movement. Philosophy makes my hands itch. Time travel makes me furrow my brow and look stupid. The original Bioshock was probably the one time that I went to throw a chair after the Andrew Ryan incident, then thoughtfully sat back on the chair and carefully retraced events. It may have required a map, some vigorous note-taking and some coffee, but in the end I continued the game, satisfied.

Anyway, the point is the more convoluted a plot gets, the quicker you lose me. And combining some seriously deep political rhetoric, multiple dimensions and time travel will always, always, make me want to punch a kitten. And I love cats. I am a cat person. This is how much it irritated me. I’ve read through the end of the game and I think if I had kept going, that kitten would have preferred to be sharing a box with hydrocyanic acid.

Elizabeth_fink1

So as a videogame, I didn’t feel that Bioshock Infinite carried the industry forward, nor did the first-person shooter evolve. There was certainly an intensely detailed inspection of topics such as racism, xenophobia and nationalism, which speaks levels for where gaming has gone over the past couple of decades, so I have to commend Irrational Games for pushing these boundaries of storytelling, ultimately it serves us better in the long run. But it didn’t have the same impact as the original and other games have since come along to showcase how, when it comes to storytelling, less can be so much more.

Previous Post

Review: Continuum: Times Up

Next Post

FIFA 14 Will Have 19 Licensed Brazilian clubs

Bryan Weatherall

Bryan Weatherall

Bryan loves writing about movies, TV shows and games and tries his best to give a balanced and honest view in all his reviews or opinion pieces on Resident Entertainment.

Related Posts

Horizon Forbidden West Review
Game Reviews

Horizon Forbidden West Review

Top Gun: Maverick Review
Movie Reviews

Top Gun: Maverick Review

Obi Wan Kenobi Episode 6 Release Date Australia
Australian Release Dates

Obi Wan Kenobi Episode 6 Release Date Australia

June 19, 2022
Hustle Movie Release Date Australia
Australian Release Dates

Hustle Movie Release Date Australia

June 7, 2022
Obi Wan Kenobi Episode 5 Release Date Australia
Australian Release Dates

Obi Wan Kenobi Episode 5 Release Date Australia

June 6, 2022
The Summer I Turned Pretty Release Date Australia
Australian Release Dates

The Summer I Turned Pretty Release Date Australia

June 6, 2022
Next Post

FIFA 14 Will Have 19 Licensed Brazilian clubs

Comments 0

  1. Scott Vater says:
    9 years ago

    Bioshock Infinite I think sucked a major dong. The story, in my opinion of course, was really the only redeeming aspect of the game…and even then the story was OMFGFBIBBQ!!1!!! amazing either. It’s just that it didn’t suck as much as the rest of the game did.

    The game play sucked (wayyy too repetitive and dull), the characters were over all very uninteresting, graphics (once you got over the wow aspect) were typical UE3 shit…I could go on forever. Game of the year? Hell no. I don’t even know if I would call Infinite game of the month when it was released.

    I think Infinite is as popular as it is because of the story. I think people beat the game and then went “WTF just happened?!” then wrote reviews right afterwards. Any TRUE analyzing of the game can show that as a game, as a FPS, it sucked and was far from anything new or special. If Infinite wins GoTY then I’m giving up on gaming forever.

    Loading...
    Reply
  2. Jennymy90 says:
    9 years ago

    It’s first person isn’t it? I never could get into the other bioshock games they just never meant much to me I skipped this one, last of us was great but I think beyond two souls might challenge it for game of the year

    Loading...
    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Reviews

Horizon Forbidden West Review
Game Reviews

Horizon Forbidden West Review

by Bryan Weatherall

Horizon Forbidden West is a game developed by Guerrilla Games and published by Sony Interactive Entertainment. It is a sequel...

Read more
Top Gun: Maverick Review

Top Gun: Maverick Review

Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore Review

Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore Review

Morbius Review

Morbius Review

Studio 666 Review

Studio 666 Review

Uncharted Movie Review

Uncharted Movie Review

Cry Macho Review

Cry Macho Review

Spider-Man No Way Home Review

Spider-Man No Way Home Review

Resident Evil: Welcome to Raccoon City Review

Resident Evil: Welcome to Raccoon City Review

Venom: Let There Be Carnage Review

Venom: Let There Be Carnage Review

Facebook Twitter Instagram

Always something to read or watch on Resident Entertainment

1,197,522 views

More About Resident Entertainment

  • Contact Us
  • About
  • Our Writers

Archives

© 2020 Resident Entertainment

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Latest news
  • Latest Reviews
  • Movie Reviews
  • Game Reviews
  • TV Show Reviews
  • How To Guides

© 2020 Resident Entertainment

%d bloggers like this: